The blog
Les Pro. de la Transfo.CIO Revolution by Airsaas

A look back at Agile en Seine 2023

Posted by
Jérôme Dard
The
22/9/2023
The AirSaaS Blog

Thanks to the whole team Agile en Seine for the organization: Amina Bourguiba, Franck Beulé, Farida Mellouk, Farida Mellouk, Arnault Etouman, Caroline Castillo, Soun Banh, Couthaier Farfra, Chrystelle Cogneville, Alain Sallon, Alain Sallon, Alain Sallon, Alain Sallon, Alain Sallon, Janro Pons, Janro Pons, Mélina Cosy, Badr Zeroual and a special thanks to 🙏 FARRA 🙏 Couthair for making possible our participation on behalf of the Pro de la Transfo/CIO Revolution.

7th edition, 940 participants, 125 speakers!

Agile en seine
Photo credit: Equipe orga AES

We have heard a lot about business agility, Lean portfolio management, OKR, agility at scale, product approach at scale, frameworks, SAFe of course... on everyone's lips, for good or for bad... ^^
In short, great feedback for the #Pro2latransfo.

4 themes were on the program:
• SCALE: around transformation at scale.
• THINK: to new ideas! .
• PRODUCT: to continue to keep what is essential alive and evolving.
• BEYOND-IT: to consider non-IT business sectors where agility is needed.

Here is our (necessarily subjective) selection of “take away” conferences we were able to attend for the AirSaaS #Pro2latransfo community and the CIO Revolution Podcas.

Opening keynote Julia de Funès on the theme “meaning and responsibility in times of crisis”

Julia de Funès sur le thème "sens et responsabilité en temps de crise"
Julia de Funès #AES23 on the theme “meaning and responsibility in times of crisis”

“There is an amalgam between trust and transparency, on the contrary trust is opposed to transparency, a register of knowledge”

“Trust pays off!”

“Having a “Manager Posture” is an antidote to charisma”

“We are enhanced by the trust we have received”

“Process? The poison is in the dose! ” “Beware of procedural overdosage”

“Businesses have jumped into well-being with “happy gadgets, candy, table football,... but it's not working! ”

“Kindness: there is nothing more violent than not competing with others (not to be confused with conflict).”

“Work is not an end, but a means, because there is always something else that justifies work. Anything that has a price is not a moral value.”

“Fear is now a sign of maturity”

“Manager's posture/impostures” = antidote to charisma”

“Leadership is more about authenticity than technique”

“The key value is courage”

“It is important to have a good balance of processes. Of course you need processes but you have to avoid overdosing and implementing processes in areas where they don't add value (for example procedural well-being?).”

“Sometimes you also have to know how to take risks (Action intelligence in the sense of Aristotle).”

“Of course, you also have to give meaning to a company. Technology is only the means.”

Agile transformation: choose your battles thanks to OKRs (REX RATP)

Anne Gabrillagues (coach) and Florence Lyon (Dir. Transfo) told us what happened behind the scenes of their transformation... in a context where the team is overwhelmed by direct and indirect requests!

 Florence Lyon (Dir. Transfo) et Anne Gabrillagues (Coach Agile)
Florence Lyon (ed. Transfo) and Anne Gabrillagues (Agile Coach)

The essence of their REX: prioritizing and managing is the key!

“Our transformation manifesto, co-written with the sponsors, served as a compass”

“We have carried out in-depth work on the concept of responsibility vs. the culture of the external service provider”

“We must not forget that processing activities come in addition to the work of the teams.”

“Our goal was to find the right degree of process to secure with a framework and release.”

“Prioritizing by value is the key!”

“Among the learnings, we encountered a lack of data that we had not taken into account enough. We developed an obsession with regular measurement ^^”

“Too many tools kill the tool, agile coaches always have plenty of tools!”

The PMU tells us about its (long) path to the Tech Company!

Nelson Dufossé,  Release Train Engineer PMU
Nelson Dufosse, Release Train Engineer

While many only see the trifecta and the PMU bars... the hidden face and the requirements vis-à-vis the IS are colossal! 2000 transactions/second, a recalculation of ratings every 5 seconds, MEPs every day... an IT department of 400 people out of 1200 employees.

Nelson Dufosse, Release Train Engineer, presented a focus on the last 4 years... the life of a Tech Company, its multitude of ambitions in parallel (Recruitment, Management Structuring, AWS migration, AWS migration, creation of new products, redesign of hardware...) and how they go about making it possible with SAFe trains.

“For 20 years, all tech companies have faced some of the same difficulties, managing to scale, working on robustness, quality, people problems...”

The organization of agility at scale

L'organisation de l'agilité à l'échelle au PMU
PMU: The organization of agility at scale

“To launch Agility at scale, we created two trains that cross departments with 125 people... 10 to 15 teams and 7 solutions per train!”

Obstacle side:

  • Heterogeneity of practices
  • Not enough communities
  • Few cooperations

Their global approach is based in particular on integrating inspection into their culture by relying on “authentic feedback + attempts”.

Innovation au PMU
Innovation approach @ PMU

“It seems that the first step in the transformation is to throw people in the pool.”

“On the contrary, the PMU has established an innovation system from a technical and functional point of view that makes it possible to try safely and to de-risk choices. A system based on trial and error readjustments...”

“Success builds trust. Trust promotes autonomy and transparency. Transparency allows for alignment.”

“Today we control our delivery from start to finish, from the idea of starting with the business to production.”

“We have transformed PI planning... our real subject is to secure the most important topics!”

Transfo PMU

In terms of skills and alignment

“As soon as we belong to a system, we need a minimum of alignment to really make progress”

“The training is integrated into the strategic plan with a budget of > 100K.”

“The PMU has also made it a strategic priority to maintain skills, in particular with the establishment of communities.” There were the creation of 6 communities: Scrum, Product, Product, QA, QA, Opes, Back, Front.

“By bringing people together... we will see that naturally all the problems will be simplified... when there are addiction problems for example it works better because people talk to each other!

Note that contributing is one of the individual goals and that communities and that this represents approximately 20 hours per month in the timetable.

A longer recruitment process

The PMU has ambitious recruitment goals for DOSI of around 70 people.

“On the recruitment side, we realized that the competence was mostly external.” The right solution is a mix of external consultancy/internal team.

And if we want to be a tech company, we need the best! In contrast to fast processes... To get the best ones, we make them go through a fairly long process with a code exercise to do at home, a review by someone from home, interviews with operational HR. All this to assess whether, beyond being a good developer, he will be a good element in a system. Because today, hard skills without software are useless”

(They estimate the recruitment time at 10:00am.)

Perspectives

The PMU's long transformation journey

“Today we started a product department, a data department to put data at the center, to unite IT and the product so that we can make decisions at the CODIR level on really strategic themes and not leave in all directions. There is a real need at this level, so we will strengthen ourselves on the SECOPS part and others.”

The Agile Lean Portfolio within the Renault Group

The IS/IT & digital teams came back to the implementation of Lean Portfolio Management (inspired by SAFe.)

They shared their Digital Portfolio governance seen as a lever for strengthening the group's strategic plan.

aka “Managing transversality in a corporate portfolio”.

Esra Soner - Aurelie Sale and Mehdi Balza

The deployment teams composed of the Performance Office, the Agile Pole, the PMOs and the Enterprise Architects deploy governance and tools that maximize opportunities to create value and growth, from the Group's OKRs to the operational level.

“The Renault LPM meets the challenges of transversal management of Value Streams. In particular how it helps Executives and Directors to align themselves with the management of transversal programs, the calculation of value and the management of budgets.”

Helped by the deployment of OKRs at the group level, the deployment of product LPM across the strategy is ongoing.

Towards another governance?

gouvernance flow
Towards another governance

“On the governance side, the system was based on governance managed by businesses.”

“The agile teams were so business-oriented... that it was difficult to know the overall strategic contribution of the company.”

“The challenge: A new governance to provide transversality.”

“The decision was taken to set up governance based on the group's value chains. A digital value stream”

“This governance allowed us to manage this complexity of the business”

Gouvernance flow Renault
The flow of governance

“It is the governance authority that owns the what and the how”

Initiative and governance life cycle

“Value driven”: a prioritization matrix

LPM prioritization criteria

The various criteria of the matrix were presented:

  • Financial criteria
  • Criteria/User Value (based on Google's Heart Framework)
  • Strategic alignment
  • Business Continuity
  • Compliance
  • Business value, continuity...

cross value stream strategic portfolio
Aurélie Sale

La Poste/Thiga: Product Portfolio Management beyond the Digital Product

Renaud CHEVALIER Product Organization Consulting Thiga/Groupe La Poste has revalued the concept of enterprise architecture, more precisely business architecture!

For him, Product Management has gone beyond the borders of digital pure players.

It is rethinking our approaches to portfolio management. Explore the specific challenges businesses face when they need to develop new capabilities and evolve their value chains. Learn how Business Architecture and Change Management play a critical role in product portfolio management, driving strategic initiatives well beyond IT.

However, he points out that despite the scale-up, two operating modes continue to coexist around the marketing product. One managed in project mode “business side” and one managed in product mode “on the IT side”.

He presented a representation of what a company must be able to do to provide a complex service:

Example of a flow on a complex marketing product (Renaud CHEVALIER/Crédit Thiga)

For him:

“Product Management is scaling up”

“Product mode is becoming more common in Tech products”

“Beware of the word “product” and the application of practices at the wrong level”

“Applied to the complex Marketing Product, Product Mode facilitates the execution of the strategy”

“5 enablers are necessary including Business Architecture” *

“Business Capability Management makes it possible to leave IT by making Product Mode holistic”

The 5 enablers are:

  • Business architecture
  • The business train tribe. > embed the open value stream
  • The combined portfolio > aka 1 single budget
  • The topology > platformization team
  • The company > portfolio > strategic consistency in managing a lean startup cycle portfolio portfolio

And in summary, business architecture is...

Business architecture (Credit Thiga)

Two examples of LPM implementation within ENGIE

Feedback on two ENGIE entities was led by Sophie Montet, Agile Coach at the Agile Center, the practice at the service of the ENGIE Group, and Laurence Bago, Agilen Transformation Manager whose mission is, in particular, the implementation of the LPM and the animation of the SAFe train.

The key challenge presented: strengthening the capacity to deliver more value.

Indeed, within the ENGIE group, more and more entities want to implement LPM to optimize investments, absorb hazards and make the most of them through agile delivery.

In short, how can you contribute to accelerating the adoption of LPM? Laurence and Sophie Montet presented a comprehensive feedback on the implementation stages, the difficulties encountered and the results to date.

One of the most rewarding conferences!

Engie Pro in 2020... before agility

Too many topics in parallel and not prioritized

Ambitions beyond the available budget

A lack of sharing of the vision roadmap

Overloaded and unaligned teams

Few projects delivered...

Le portfolio Excel Engie avant 2020
Before ^^

Progressive adoption within the group

Entities choose how to scale (or not)

Today SAFe for 6 entities

Spotity template for 1 entity

Hybrid model for 1 entity

8 SAFe trains launched in 4 years In the group

The LACE (Lean-Agile Center of Excellence) in support

Community of practice activator

Over 45 Leading SAFe certification training sessions

Support for agile transformations (trains, LPM, specific workshops such as pitch, MVP, prioritization or value chains)

Towards another function combining several devices: OKR/Value/LPM and PI

OKR LPM PI EPIC
EPIC at the center and Lean Portfolio Management at the forefront

How do you prioritize when you only have “100 potatoes”?

More than 45 projects in the entity, an overloaded team... The first thing was to align everyone with an OKR session.

Then start setting up LPM with EPIC and prioritization.

Then implement horizons to be sure to maintain capacity for the future

PI planning “we put everyone on a train”!

Four steps to help accelerate the adoption of LPM in the Engie Group

The first step to acquire was vocabulary...

The second was role implementation and a mindset that changes between IT and business.

Third point for everything related to governance > strat trim review + endowment review >

Finally, the fourth step: continuous improvement, work on the measured value

Prioritizing initiatives

Each initiative gets a grade. On the Fibonacci sequence on the value.

1 hour and 30 minutes to do the notations: 10 min/subject

3 min to pitch benefits and how to respond to/contribute to strategic axes by the bearer.

Observed benefits of implementing Lean Portfolio Management at Engie Home Service

  • Knowledge and ownership of the subjects by all
  • Better involvement of business teams and business owners
  • Better strategic alignment
  • Improving delivery

The new challenges

  • Fluidification of the flow/ Identification of WIP limits
  • Quantifying expected benefits and better measuring ROI
  • Drive by the expected results
See all posts →